The Limits of Motivation-Driven Management and the Power of System-Based Organizations


 Read the original article (in Japanese):【モチベーションの専門家が教える】現代の若者たちの「働きがい」が低下した、たった1つの理由 | ライバルはいるか？ | ダイヤモンド・オンライン


The claim that “young people today have lost their sense of work fulfillment” is often repeated. But is that really the case? In reality, it may simply be that the distinction between work fulfillment and work ease has become clearer. Those who prioritize income aim for positions and promotions, while those who value work-life balance seek stable environments. This basic tendency has remained consistent over time. It's not that younger generations have lost motivation entirely—rather, the sources of motivation have become more diverse.

What’s truly important for companies is to create systems that don’t rely on individual motivation to function. Companies like Amazon, McDonald’s, and Toyota have built mechanisms that produce stable outcomes regardless of how motivated each employee may be. In such organizations, productivity is not driven by internal competition, but by strategic role assignment and efficient systems.

What Defines Companies That Don’t Rely on Motivation

As organizations grow, reliance on individual discretion or passion becomes less sustainable. Successful companies share common traits:

  • Amazon: Automates logistics and cloud operations with data, reducing reliance on individual skill or effort.

  • McDonald’s: Standardizes tasks so that anyone can deliver consistent quality by following manuals.

  • Toyota: Uses the Toyota Production System to manage quality and efficiency without relying on individual craftsmanship.

  • Uber: Matches drivers and customers with algorithms, eliminating the need for salesmanship.

  • Netflix: Uses viewer data to optimize content production, avoiding dependence on intuition or guesswork.

Each of these companies has built systems where outcomes are consistent regardless of who is working, ensuring scalable and stable operations.

The Risk of Over-Sterilization and How to Address It

There is merit to the concern that over-sanitized work environments may sap organizational energy. Excessive focus on avoiding risk can suppress opportunities for challenge and growth, undermining a company’s competitiveness. But it would be reductive to label this simply as “declining motivation.”

  • Those who prioritize income thrive in competitive roles,

  • while those who value work-life balance serve best in stable support positions.

Rather than demanding high motivation from everyone, companies should recognize these differing values and design systems and role assignments that fit a range of working styles.

Conclusion: What Companies Should Truly Focus On

In the end, the priority for businesses should not be “raising motivation.”
Instead, they should focus on creating well-structured systems and assigning roles effectively so that operations run smoothly regardless of individual attitudes.

When such systems are in place, even employees with lower motivation can contribute, and highly motivated individuals can be given opportunities to take on more challenging roles.

When we talk about how young people work today, the focus shouldn't be on whether they are “motivated” or not. The real question is: how do we design organizations that function effectively as a whole?


Read in Japanese↓

モチベーション至上主義の限界と、システムで回る組織の強さ（2025.2.27）

Read more articles (in Japanese)↓

「増えない給料」の真因と日本経済の停滞を生む構造（2025.2.26）

コメント

コメントを投稿

このブログの人気の投稿

Why Aren’t Wages Rising in Japan?

イメージ
  Why Aren’t Wages Rising in Japan? — How the Labor Share Ratio and Retained Earnings Are Stalling Economic Growth Read the original article (in Japanese): 生産性3割アップも「増えない給料」　原因は「貯めこむ大企業」にあった | TBS NEWS DIG Chapter 1: The Illusion of Wage Growth Despite government announcements of a “historic wage increase,” most workers in Japan feel no real difference in their paychecks. The reality is that real wages have barely moved in 25 years , even though labor productivity has risen by roughly 30% during the same period. This growth rate exceeds that of major European economies like France and Germany. The popular narrative — “wages haven’t increased because productivity is low” — is no longer credible. The real question is this: Why are companies making more money, yet not paying workers more? Chapter 2: Record Corporate Profits, Yet No Pay Raises The most glaring figure is Japan’s retained earnings , also known as corporate savings or internal reserves. In 1998: approximately...
続きを読む

Proposing the Radical Idea of a “Tenure-Based Retirement System”

イメージ
Read the original article (in Japanese): 「もう長すぎた…」宇宙飛行士・野口聡一氏が57歳でJAXAを辞めた納得のワケ( ダイヤモンド・オンライン ) The Reality Behind the 45-Year Retirement Debate The ongoing public debate around the “45-year retirement” and early retirement plans in Japan was initially intended to encourage self-directed career development. Yet, many workers interpret these initiatives as thinly veiled attempts to push them out. As astronaut Soichi Noguchi has noted, Japan’s work culture tends to reward compliance over skill-building or career ownership. If we want to change that, we need structural reform—not just slogans. The Proposal: A Tenure-Based Retirement System A better alternative is the Tenure-Based Retirement System . Rather than setting a fixed age for retirement, the idea is to define an employee’s career cycle within a company by tenure—say, a 20-year maximum. Such a system allows for natural career reflection without age-based discrimination. More importantly, it promotes a mindset where workers are exp...
続きを読む

How “Incompetent Seniors” Drive Young Employees Away Through Broken OJT Structures

イメージ
 Read the original article (in Japanese): なぜ「OJT」ばかりの企業に若者は定着しないのか？　上司が部下育成を勘違いする理由 「うちはOJTで育てる」と胸を張る企業がある。OJTとはOn-the-Job Trainingの略で、現場で実務を通じて部 www.itmedia.co.jp Introduction: Is “We Train Through OJT” a Cop-Out? “We develop people through OJT”—how many times have we heard this in Japanese workplaces? On-the-Job Training (OJT) is originally meant to be a practical learning method where skills are honed through real work. Yet in practice, many companies abuse this term as a way to justify throwing new employees into unfamiliar tasks without guidance. This leads to frustration, underperformance, and ultimately, resignation. This article explores why such “OJT in name only” is problematic and what structural improvements companies must make—drawing comparisons to the foundational training methods found in sports and the arts. 1. Without Form, Growth Can’t Begin Karate, Baseball, and Art: Why Mastery Begins with Form Karate has kata. Baseball has standard stances and pitching mechani...
続きを読む