Even Elon Musk struggles to demand self-sacrifice from employees—let alone companies in Japan.

 

Read the original article (in Japanese):

Prologue: When Even Top Talent Walks Away

Robert Kiel, head of legal at xAI, resigned after being forced to choose between work or family. Under Elon Musk, there was unmatched drive, a mix of genius and madness, and a vision to change the future. Compensation and career value were off the charts. In short, the biggest imaginable “sense of purpose” was on the table. And yet, even talented executives walked away.

This fact delivers a blunt message: it’s not that “Musk can get away with it” but rather that “even Musk can’t sustain it.”

Chapter 1: Musk-Style Management as an Outlier

Musk’s way of running companies rests on elements far outside the norm:

  • Overwhelming charisma: one word from him can move markets.

  • Humanity-scale challenges: EVs, space travel, AI—projects that alter history.

  • Extraordinary rewards: sky-high pay, equity, and the unique career value of having worked under Musk.

With this rare “triple set” in place, some employees accepted the demand for self-sacrifice. And yet, even under such conditions, when faced with the choice of family or work, top talent still left. If even an outlier cannot hold people, the model is fundamentally unsustainable.

Chapter 2: Self-Sacrifice in Japanese Companies

In Japan, it is common to hear: “Because the president sacrifices himself, employees must do the same.” But this is a sleight of hand.

  • The president’s self-sacrifice is part of ownership. Rewards and risks are directly linked; it is a responsibility of position.

  • The employee’s self-sacrifice is disproportionate. Rewards are limited, but the personal cost is high.

And yet many leaders lean on nostalgia: “I used to sleep at the office too.” In reality, however, Japanese companies often offer ordinary pay, domestic-only opportunities, and leaders who lean heavily on spirit rather than vision. With none of Musk’s outsized factors, demanding self-sacrifice inevitably accelerates talent drain.

Chapter 3: The Danger of Treating Outliers as the Norm

The existence of Musk-like leaders need not be denied. They should be observed as outliers. The problem arises when their model is treated as a universal rule.

FactorxAI under MuskTypical Japanese firms
CharismaGlobal influenceInward-looking, rooted in spirit
Scale of outcomesEVs, space, AI—paradigm shiftsDomestic and incremental
RewardsHigh pay + equity + career prestigeAverage salary, limited career value

If xAI could not hold onto talent with all these factors maximized, then the chance of success for average Japanese firms copying the same approach is statistically near zero.

Chapter 4: Probability and Prudence

Management is not gambling. Success requires designing for the average, not betting on extremes.

  • The probability of replicating outliers is vanishingly small.

  • The more talented the individual, the more rational their choice: when forced into a binary between family and work, they leave.

  • Demanding self-sacrifice under ordinary conditions leads only to becoming a loser in the talent market.

Outliers should be studied, not worshiped.

Chapter 5: A Workplace That Demands Binary Choices Is Already Broken

Here lies the core issue:

  • The very question “family or work” is a design failure.

  • Without private life and balance, sustainable performance and creativity cannot exist.

  • Firms that demand employees sacrifice their lives will lose top talent first, leaving only the exhausted behind.

Self-sacrifice is not a virtue. It is a symptom of immature design.

Chapter 6: The Self-Sacrifice of Presidents and Employees Is Not the Same

  • For presidents, self-sacrifice is tied to direct ownership of risks and rewards.

  • For employees, it becomes sacrifice for someone else’s gain, while carrying personal costs.

To confuse the two and declare, “I sacrificed, so you must too” is not management logic but an imposition of sentiment.

Chapter 7: The Minimum Conditions for Sustainable Management

Rejecting self-sacrifice is not indulgence—it is a sign of maturity. At minimum:

  1. Eliminate false binaries: remove “family or work” from the framework.

  2. Align rewards with burdens: make costs and benefits transparent and proportional.

  3. Redefine success: measure results in outcomes, quality, and sustainability—not hours or sacrifice.

Without these, no company can compete in the long run.

Conclusion: Self-Sacrifice Cannot Work in Ordinary Companies

Elon Musk himself could not hold onto talent.
So how could ordinary Japanese firms, with modest scale and pay, hope to do so?

Companies that demand employees sacrifice their lives will inevitably fail in the market. Rational management means not copying outliers but designing systems that succeed at the average.


Read in Japanese↓

イーロン・マスクですら社員への滅私要求は難しい（2025.8.20）

Read more articles (in Japanese)↓

勝つために「休む」ことが、有能な社長、社員の考え方と働き方（2025.8.18）

コメント

コメントを投稿

このブログの人気の投稿

Why Aren’t Wages Rising in Japan?

イメージ
  Why Aren’t Wages Rising in Japan? — How the Labor Share Ratio and Retained Earnings Are Stalling Economic Growth Read the original article (in Japanese): 生産性3割アップも「増えない給料」　原因は「貯めこむ大企業」にあった | TBS NEWS DIG Chapter 1: The Illusion of Wage Growth Despite government announcements of a “historic wage increase,” most workers in Japan feel no real difference in their paychecks. The reality is that real wages have barely moved in 25 years , even though labor productivity has risen by roughly 30% during the same period. This growth rate exceeds that of major European economies like France and Germany. The popular narrative — “wages haven’t increased because productivity is low” — is no longer credible. The real question is this: Why are companies making more money, yet not paying workers more? Chapter 2: Record Corporate Profits, Yet No Pay Raises The most glaring figure is Japan’s retained earnings , also known as corporate savings or internal reserves. In 1998: approximately...
続きを読む

Proposing the Radical Idea of a “Tenure-Based Retirement System”

イメージ
Read the original article (in Japanese): 「もう長すぎた…」宇宙飛行士・野口聡一氏が57歳でJAXAを辞めた納得のワケ( ダイヤモンド・オンライン ) The Reality Behind the 45-Year Retirement Debate The ongoing public debate around the “45-year retirement” and early retirement plans in Japan was initially intended to encourage self-directed career development. Yet, many workers interpret these initiatives as thinly veiled attempts to push them out. As astronaut Soichi Noguchi has noted, Japan’s work culture tends to reward compliance over skill-building or career ownership. If we want to change that, we need structural reform—not just slogans. The Proposal: A Tenure-Based Retirement System A better alternative is the Tenure-Based Retirement System . Rather than setting a fixed age for retirement, the idea is to define an employee’s career cycle within a company by tenure—say, a 20-year maximum. Such a system allows for natural career reflection without age-based discrimination. More importantly, it promotes a mindset where workers are exp...
続きを読む

How “Incompetent Seniors” Drive Young Employees Away Through Broken OJT Structures

イメージ
 Read the original article (in Japanese): なぜ「OJT」ばかりの企業に若者は定着しないのか？　上司が部下育成を勘違いする理由 「うちはOJTで育てる」と胸を張る企業がある。OJTとはOn-the-Job Trainingの略で、現場で実務を通じて部 www.itmedia.co.jp Introduction: Is “We Train Through OJT” a Cop-Out? “We develop people through OJT”—how many times have we heard this in Japanese workplaces? On-the-Job Training (OJT) is originally meant to be a practical learning method where skills are honed through real work. Yet in practice, many companies abuse this term as a way to justify throwing new employees into unfamiliar tasks without guidance. This leads to frustration, underperformance, and ultimately, resignation. This article explores why such “OJT in name only” is problematic and what structural improvements companies must make—drawing comparisons to the foundational training methods found in sports and the arts. 1. Without Form, Growth Can’t Begin Karate, Baseball, and Art: Why Mastery Begins with Form Karate has kata. Baseball has standard stances and pitching mechani...
続きを読む